Myanmar faces a historic ruling at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on Thursday over accusations that its military committed genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority in 2017.
The case, filed by The Gambia in November 2019, could lead to the first time an international court finds a state guilty of committing genocide.
Since the 1948 Genocide Convention was adopted after the Holocaust, individuals have been prosecuted for genocide in conflicts including Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia. But no state has been found guilty of the crime by an international court.
Arsalan Suleman, the lawyer leading The Gambia’s case, said a ruling in its favour would strengthen the Genocide Convention and international accountability for crimes committed by states.
The case concerns the mass expulsion of Rohingya people from Myanmar’s Rakhine State in August and September 2017. The military operation forced hundreds of thousands to flee into neighbouring Bangladesh.
Survivors reported killings, torture and mass rape by Myanmar soldiers. Human rights organisations and a United Nations fact-finding mission documented the alleged atrocities.
Myanmar has denied accusations of genocide and ethnic cleansing, maintaining that its military was responding to attacks by Rohingya militants through what it described as clearance operations.
A 2018 UN report, based on hundreds of interviews, said the military’s response was grossly disproportionate to the security threats. It recommended that senior military figures be investigated for genocide in Rakhine State and crimes against humanity in other parts of the country. Myanmar rejected the findings.
The ICJ, established in 1945 to resolve disputes between states, became the legal avenue for the case because Myanmar was not a signatory to the International Criminal Court.
The Gambia filed the case with support from the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, arguing that every state has an interest in ensuring compliance with the Genocide Convention.
It accused the Myanmar state, rather than only its military, of violating the convention. Myanmar challenged The Gambia’s right to bring the case, but the ICJ ruled that it had legal standing to proceed.
The case attracted international attention when Aung San Suu Kyi, then Myanmar’s civilian leader and a Nobel Peace Prize laureate, personally led the country’s initial defence at The Hague.
Her decision to defend Myanmar’s actions and her refusal to condemn the military drew criticism from supporters who had previously admired her.
Following the military coup in 2021, which removed Suu Kyi from power and led to her arrest, a legal team appointed by the military took over the defence.
Proving genocide remains difficult under international law. Judges require strong evidence that the accused intended to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, in whole or in part.
Where there is no explicit programme of genocide, the evidence must show that genocidal intent is the only reasonable explanation for the actions in question.
A similar legal challenge arose when Bosnia-Herzegovina filed a genocide case against Serbia in 1993. In 2007, the ICJ ruled that the 1995 Srebrenica massacre constituted genocide but found insufficient evidence that Serbia itself had the required genocidal intent. It ruled that Serbia had failed to prevent the genocide.
Myanmar’s defence has also argued that evidence of war crimes does not automatically establish genocidal intent.
Suu Kyi previously told the court that The Gambia had misrepresented a complex conflict and that possible war crimes against the Rohingya did not prove genocide.
But Suleman said The Gambia had presented evidence of decades of discrimination against the Rohingya, including laws and policies that restricted their access to education, healthcare, employment and freedom of movement.
He cited Myanmar’s 1982 citizenship law as part of the evidence, arguing that the long history of discrimination helped establish the context and intent behind the 2017 military operations.
A ruling against Myanmar would carry significant international consequences, although the ICJ has no mechanism to impose a penalty following its verdict and there is no right of appeal.
The ruling could further damage the international reputation of military leader Min Aung Hlaing, who was responsible for the military operations in 2017 and has sought to improve relations with other countries.
However, the impact on Myanmar’s relations with neighbouring Asian countries may be limited, while Western governments could attach greater importance to the judgment.
For Rohingya refugees, the case represents a chance for international recognition of their suffering.
Mohammed Nowkim, who fled the Rakhine town of Buthidaung in 2017 and now lives in Canada, said a ruling in The Gambia’s favour would acknowledge years of suffering and denial.
More than one million Rohingya remain in refugee camps in Bangladesh, where they face difficult living conditions and declining international support.
Rohingya activists hope the verdict will encourage countries to work towards a solution that allows refugees to return safely to Myanmar.
But their return faces major obstacles. Rakhine State has been devastated by fighting between Myanmar’s military and the Arakan Army, which controls much of the territory and has the support of many ethnic Rakhine people who oppose the return of the Rohingya.
Many Rohingya villages have also been destroyed, while international attention and funding for the refugees have declined.
Even a historic ruling by the ICJ may not resolve the political and security challenges preventing the Rohingya from returning home.
Erizia Rubyjeana
Follow us on:
