A Federal High Court in Abuja has ruled in favour of former Benue State Governor, Gabriel Suswam, in his legal dispute with the All Progressives Congress (APC) over the party’s 2027 Benue North-East senatorial ticket.
In a judgment delivered on Wednesday, Justice Inyang Ekwo declared that the APC acted unlawfully by replacing Suswam with incumbent Senator Emmanuel Udende, despite his victory in the party’s primary election.
The court held that the substitution violated the Electoral Act, the 1999 Constitution and the APC constitution. It consequently directed the party to submit Suswam’s name to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) as its candidate for the Benue North-East Senatorial District in the 2027 general election.
Suswam won the APC primary conducted on May 18, 2026, with 131,083 votes, defeating Udende, who secured 1,364 votes.
However, the party subsequently forwarded Udende’s name to INEC, prompting Suswam to approach the court to challenge the decision.
In suit number FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026, the former governor sought a determination of whether the APC could replace a candidate who had won its primary without complying with the Electoral Act, the party’s constitution and its electoral guidelines.
He also asked the court to recognise him as the duly elected candidate and compel the party to submit his name to INEC.
Before considering the substantive issues, Justice Ekwo dismissed preliminary objections by the APC and Udende, who argued that the court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the matter because it concerned the internal affairs of a political party.
Rejecting the argument, the judge held that aspirants who participated in party primaries could approach the court where they alleged that the conduct or outcome of an election violated the Electoral Act or the party’s constitution and guidelines.
He maintained that the Electoral Act took precedence over a political party’s internal regulations, adding that the dispute was therefore not beyond judicial scrutiny.
“Therefore, the issue of internal affairs is of no moment,” he held.
The judge also dismissed the defendants’ argument that Suswam lacked the legal standing, or locus standi, to institute the case
He ruled that Suswam’s participation in the APC primary gave him the requisite legal standing to challenge the party’s decision. He equally rejected the argument that the suit was statute-barred, finding insufficient evidence to support the objection.
On the substantive dispute, Ekwo found that the APC and Udende failed to provide sufficient evidence to disprove Suswam’s victory.
He noted that INEC monitored the primary election and produced a report confirming its outcome. According to the judge, neither the party nor Udende challenged the commission’s report or presented an alternative result establishing Udende as the winner.
The court consequently held that there was no sufficient basis to disregard INEC’s findings.
“Therefore, the court has no reason not to act on the INEC report since its probative value has not been diminished,” he held.
Ekwo also faulted the APC’s reliance on a report by its appeal committee to justify replacing Suswam.
He observed that the report was dated May 18, 2026, the same day the primary election was conducted, and noted that there was no evidence that Suswam was given an opportunity to respond to the allegations or findings before the party substituted his name.
The judge held that the process violated Suswam’s right to a fair hearing.
Having found that the former governor established his claims, Ekwo declared the suit meritorious and granted the reliefs sought, affirming Suswam as the APC’s candidate for the 2027 Benue North-East senatorial election.
Goodness Anunobi
Follow us on:
